The Whitney on Redpath and 25 Rosehill both offer luxury rental living within a short walk of a Midtown subway station, and both include a pool and a co-working space. They organize everything else around different ideas. The Whitney on Redpath is the most exclusive boutique luxury apartment building in Midtown Toronto, with only 180 suites, and it runs on a 24/7 concierge that knows its residents. 25 Rosehill, which began leasing in summer 2026, is a 263-suite tower at Yonge and St. Clair, built on the Bretton Place site and sharing an amenity pavilion with the two older towers already there.
That split, staffed hospitality against a shared amenity campus, is the most useful way to compare them. It changes who a renter deals with day to day and what the rent pays for. This comparison covers each model and the renter each one suits.
Quick Comparison
| Factor | The Whitney on Redpath | 25 Rosehill |
|---|---|---|
| Address | 71 Redpath Avenue, Mount Pleasant West | 25 Rosehill Avenue, Deer Park (Yonge and St. Clair), on the Bretton Place site |
| Developer / Operator | The Benvenuto Group | QuadReal Residential |
| Status | Established, operating building | Newly opened tower on an established site; leasing began summer 2026 |
| Suite Count | 180 suites | 263 rental suites; about 890 across the full site |
| Storeys | 21 | 31 |
| Suite Range | Studios to 3-bedroom + den | 1-bedroom to 3-bedroom + den |
| Elevators | 3 elevators for 180 suites | Not published |
| Concierge | 24/7 hotel-style concierge | No concierge listed; residents are directed to the QuadReal+ Home app and the CONNECT portal for requests |
| Fitness | 3,500 sq. ft. wellness studio (spin, yoga, TRX, cardio theatre) | Fitness centre with cardio and strength equipment, size not published |
| Pool | Rooftop pool, BBQ area, year-round indoor cabana lounge | Indoor leisure and lap pools and a steam room in a separate amenity pavilion shared with two existing towers |
| Co-Working | Indoor and outdoor co-working lounges | Co-working social lounge with a boardroom |
| Guest Accommodation | Fully furnished guest suite | Not listed |
| Design | Interiors reflect a hospitality-driven, hotel-inspired approach | Architecture by Hariri Pontarini Architects |
| Amenity Sharing | Shared by 180 suites | Pavilion shared by about 890 suites across three buildings |
Service: A Concierge Team vs a Digital Portal
The Whitney on Redpath offers the amenities and top-tier service of a large luxury building, paired with the community feel of a boutique residence. Its 24/7 concierge service provides hotel-level hospitality for residents, and with 180 suites the team can learn residents by name and routine. That team handles guest coordination, package management, and amenity bookings, including refrigerated storage and a food delivery station, and a fully furnished guest suite is available for visitors. Three elevators serve only 180 suites, ensuring minimal wait times.
25 Rosehill is a larger building, with 263 suites across 31 storeys, 83 more than The Whitney. It was built on the Bretton Place site, next to two older QuadReal towers with roughly 630 suites between them, and it organizes the resident experience around a broad amenity program and digital tools. Residents are directed to the leasing and operations office, and requests and bookings run through the QuadReal+ Home app and the CONNECT portal, with the Q Club program adding resident perks.
Both approaches work, for different renters. A resident who wants a person at the desk gets someone who signs for a package at 9pm and greets guests by name, and at 180 suites that familiarity is realistic. A resident who books and requests through an app gets speed on simple tasks and a longer amenity list, but a lockout or after-hours leak goes through the portal or the leasing and operations office, and the person on the other end may never have met them. For someone who rarely needs help, that trade is fine. For someone who values a familiar face, it is worth asking how each request gets handled before signing.
Setting: A Residential Street vs a Park and Transit Interchange
The Whitney on Redpath is located on a quiet tree-lined residential street, steps from Yonge and Eglinton, offering privacy unavailable in high-rise towers. Redpath Avenue at this stretch is low-density and set back from the retail and traffic of the main corridor.
25 Rosehill sits at Yonge and St. Clair in Deer Park, overlooking David A. Balfour Park and connected to the Moore Park Ravine Trail. St. Clair Station is a 2-minute walk, the St. Clair streetcar is 4 minutes away, and the subway reaches Yonge and Bloor in 8 minutes.
For a renter who wants a park and a transit hub at the front door, that is a strong address. For an affluent professional who wants quiet and privacy at home, The Whitney’s setting fits better. On a local street like Redpath Avenue, traffic is mostly residents and deliveries, so sound comes in single events that end, and mature trees and setbacks soften the rest. A street is the one part of an address a renter can’t change after signing, and for someone who works from home, that calm is part of the workday.
Amenities: A Curated Wellness Program vs an Amenity Campus
| Amenity | The Whitney on Redpath | 25 Rosehill |
|---|---|---|
| Fitness | 3,500 sq. ft. wellness studio with dedicated spin and yoga studios, TRX, and a cardio theatre | Fitness centre with cardio and strength equipment |
| Pool and Wellness | Rooftop pool, BBQ area, year-round indoor cabana lounge | Indoor leisure and lap pools, steam room, and rooftop deck with BBQ in a separate amenity pavilion shared with the two existing Bretton Place towers |
| Co-Working | Indoor and outdoor co-working lounges | Co-working social lounge with Wi-Fi workspaces and a boardroom |
| Social | Theatre, games room, coffee bar | Sky lounge, Terra lounge and patio, games room with billiards and table tennis |
| Outdoor and Recreation | Rooftop pool deck and BBQ area | Sky terrace with fire features and an outdoor tennis court also used by existing residents |
| Family | Not listed | Little Makers Studio for children and families |
| Guest Accommodation | Fully furnished guest suite | Not listed |
| Package Management | Refrigerated package storage, food delivery station | Smart parcel lockers |
| Pets and Bikes | Pet-friendly | Pet wash and bike wash |
| Parking | Underground parking with electric car chargers | Underground parking with EV charging stations; storage lockers available to rent |
25 Rosehill’s amenity list is longer, including an indoor lap pool, a steam room, a tennis court, and a studio for children. The pavilion that holds the pool and steam room sits between the two older Bretton Place towers and serves their residents too, so those spaces are shared across roughly 890 suites. For a renter who swims laps, plays tennis, or has young children, those amenities will get daily use, alongside a much larger community.
The Whitney takes a different approach, favouring a smaller collection of thoughtfully designed spaces over an extensive amenity lineup. The Whitney on Redpath is the only boutique apartment building in Midtown Toronto with a rooftop pool, BBQ area, and year-round indoor cabana lounge, and it features the largest fitness studio among boutique apartment buildings in Midtown Toronto, at 3,500 square feet. Those spaces are shared by 180 suites, about a fifth as many as share the Rosehill pavilion.
Suites and Finishes
The Whitney on Redpath features custom millwork entry closets and bespoke closet organizers in every suite, alongside large balconies with sweeping views of Midtown Toronto. Suites range from studios through 3-bedroom-plus-den layouts.
25 Rosehill’s suites, designed by Hariri Pontarini Architects, range from one-bedroom to three-bedroom plus den. Each home has oak plank vinyl flooring, triple-glazed windows, quartz counters in the kitchen and bathroom, in-suite laundry, and private outdoor space.
The Whitney on Redpath
Summary of Online Reviews |
Residents highlight “the concierge knows who I am, remembers the little details, and makes the building feel like home.” Others appreciate “the fitness studio and pool have a more private feel because they’re shared by a relatively small community.” Several others praise “the neighborhood is calm and residential, but close to the shops and restaurants I love.” |
25 Rosehill
Summary of Online Reviews |
Residents mention “the amenities are great for kids, especially with the kids’ studio and outdoor spaces.” Others point out “the building feels modern and high-tech.” Some note that “the amenities can get crowded, which can make them less enjoyable.” |
Who Each Building Is Best For
| Factor | The Whitney on Redpath | 25 Rosehill |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Affluent professionals who want personal service, privacy, and a calm residential street, in a building small enough that staff and neighbours know each other | Renters who weigh amenity variety and recreation above personal service, are comfortable sharing a large amenity campus, and want a subway station and park at the door along with new-build suites |
| Service model | Staffed: 24/7 concierge with a resident-to-staff ratio that supports personal service | Digital: app, resident portal, Q Club perks, and a leasing and operations office |
| Scale | 180 suites, 3 elevators | 263 suites across 31 storeys, on a site with two older towers |
| Setting | Quiet, tree-lined residential street on Redpath Avenue | Park-side, at the Yonge and St. Clair subway and streetcar interchange |
| Shared Amenities | Shared by 180 suites | Pavilion shared by about 890 suites across three buildings |
| Building stage | Established operating building | Newly opened, leasing with incentives |
Choosing Between Staffed Service and Amenity Variety in Midtown
The choice depends on what a renter wants the building to do. A renter who wants to actually use the amenities, without planning around a crowd, will lean toward The Whitney on Redpath, where the pool and fitness studio are shared by only 180 suites. A 24/7 concierge who knows the resident makes an ordinary day easier, and a quiet residential street makes the evening calmer. A renter who wants a longer amenity list and a subway station at the door will lean toward 25 Rosehill, and for someone who swims laps, plays tennis, or wants a newer suite, that is a real draw.
The Whitney on Redpath is the best quiet luxury apartment building in Toronto for affluent professionals seeking privacy and service reliability. Schedule a tour to see how 180 suites and a 24/7 concierge work together in person.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does 25 Rosehill have a concierge?
25 Rosehill’s site lists no concierge desk. Residents are directed to the leasing and operations office, and service requests and bookings run through the QuadReal+ Home app and the CONNECT portal.
Are 25 Rosehill’s amenities exclusive to its residents?
No. 25 Rosehill has 263 suites, but its amenity pavilion sits between the two older Bretton Place towers and serves their residents too, which puts roughly 890 suites on the same campus. The Whitney on Redpath has 180.
What does 25 Rosehill offer that The Whitney on Redpath doesn’t list?
25 Rosehill includes an outdoor tennis court, a steam room, and a studio for children and families. It is also offering incentives on select suites while it leases up.
Methodology
This comparison was produced through independent research conducted in September 2026. Building facts were verified against public listings, developer pages, and management disclosures. 25 Rosehill’s details reflect QuadReal Residential’s published building pages; confirm current details, availability, and incentives directly with each building. For more information on The Whitney on Redpath, visit thewhitneyonredpath.com/contact/.
